Types of Preventive Measures in Criminal Proceedings
Personal Undertaking, Personal Surety, Bail, House Arrest and Detention
The Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine provides for five types of preventive measures. A personal undertaking involves imposing specific obligations on a suspect by court order, including the obligation to appear when summoned. Personal surety is an undertaking by individuals who are deemed trustworthy to ensure the suspect's proper conduct. Bail requires the deposit of funds into a designated account as security for compliance with the obligations imposed. House arrest prohibits a person from leaving their residence either around the clock or during specified hours. Detention is an exceptional preventive measure that may be imposed only where less restrictive measures are insufficient to address the relevant risks.
When a Preventive Measure Can Be Modified
New Circumstances, Reduced Risks and Proper Procedural Conduct
During an investigation, a suspect or their lawyer may initiate a review of a preventive measure if circumstances arise that were not taken into account when it was initially imposed. A reduction or disappearance of the relevant risks may allow the court to ease the restrictions. To this end, a reasoned motion must be submitted together with supporting documents seeking a modification of the preventive measure.
Deterioration in Health, Family Circumstances and Other Evidence
A deterioration in a person's health or changes in their family circumstances may indicate that the relevant risks have decreased and may constitute grounds for easing a preventive measure. Such circumstances must be supported by appropriate evidence, including official medical reports or documents confirming responsibility for dependent children.
Revocation of a Preventive Measure
When Restrictions Are No Longer Necessary or the Proceedings Have Changed
A preventive measure must be revoked when it is no longer necessary. A court order imposing a preventive measure also ceases to have effect upon expiry of the relevant period. Where criminal proceedings are closed by the prosecutor or the court, or an acquittal is delivered, the preventive measure is revoked entirely. In such cases, a person held in custody must be released immediately.
Replacing Detention with House Arrest
Conditions for House Arrest and Possible Obligations
House arrest may be imposed on a person suspected of committing an offence punishable by imprisonment (Article 181 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine). When imposing this measure, the court may require the person to:
- wear an electronic monitoring device to track their whereabouts;
- refrain from communicating with specified individuals, including witnesses or victims;
- surrender their international travel documents for safekeeping;
- appear before the competent authority whenever required.
These restrictions are intended to ensure compliance with procedural obligations without imposing actual and complete isolation. A successful modification of the preventive measure allows the person to return to a more normal way of life.
Bail in Criminal Proceedings
Determining the Amount, Payment and Return of Bail
The payment of bail in criminal proceedings is governed, in particular, by Article 182 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine. The amount is determined with regard to the gravity of the offence, the person's financial circumstances and the relevant risks. Once the preventive measure ceases to have effect, any funds not forfeited to the State are returned to the person who provided the bail, on the basis of a court judgment or ruling that has entered into legal force.
Reducing the Amount of Bail or Applying a Less Restrictive Measure
If the amount set is objectively unaffordable, the lawyer may submit a motion seeking its reduction. The court may lower the amount or replace bail with a less restrictive measure, such as a personal undertaking. Under the law, the amount of bail must not be manifestly excessive for the person concerned.
Motion to Modify a Preventive Measure
Who May Apply and Which Court Has Jurisdiction
An application may be submitted by a suspect or accused person, their defence lawyer or legal representative, as well as by the prosecutor. During the pre-trial investigation, the motion is considered by the investigating judge with territorial jurisdiction over the pre-trial investigation body. Once the indictment has been referred to the court, the motion is considered by the court hearing the case.
Circumstances, Evidence and the Relief Sought
The motion must identify new circumstances that were not considered when the preventive measure was initially imposed and provide reasons supported by references to the applicable legal provisions. It must be accompanied by evidence supporting the defence's position. The section setting out the relief sought must clearly specify the request to the court: to modify or revoke the preventive measure.
Appealing a Court Order Imposing a Preventive Measure
Appeal, Time Limits and the Defence's Arguments
The Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine specifies which court orders may be appealed. During the pre-trial investigation, these include, in particular, investigating judge's rulings imposing detention or house arrest. During court proceedings, rulings concerning detention may also be appealed.
An appeal against such rulings must be filed directly with the court of appeal within five days of their pronouncement. Other rulings of the court of first instance may be appealed separately, where permitted by the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine, within seven days through the court that issued the ruling. A successful appeal against an order imposing a preventive measure makes it possible to correct judicial errors, particularly where the alleged risks have not been substantiated or the measure imposed is disproportionate.
Factors Considered by the Court
Risks of Absconding, Influencing Witnesses and Obstructing Proceedings
The imposition of a preventive measure must be based on risks that the prosecutor is required to establish. The court assesses the likelihood of the person absconding, destroying evidence, committing another criminal offence or continuing the alleged offence, influencing witnesses or other participants in the proceedings, or otherwise obstructing the proceedings. The greater the degree of risk substantiated by the evidence, the more restrictive the preventive measure the court may impose.
Personal Circumstances, Social Ties and Proportionality of Restrictions
The court takes into account the person's age, health, family circumstances, place of employment, reputation and other relevant personal information (Article 178 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine). The preventive measure imposed must be proportionate to the risks established. Strong social ties may indicate a lower risk of absconding and serve as a significant argument in favour of a less restrictive measure.
Documents Required to Prepare the Defence Position
Court Order, Materials Relating to the Notice of Suspicion and Evidence of New Circumstances
To support the application before the court, the lawyer prepares a set of documents that may include:
- a copy of the court order imposing the preventive measure, the notice of suspicion and other procedural documents;
- certificates from the person's place of employment and residence, as well as references or character assessments;
- medical records and documents confirming the person's health condition;
- written undertakings from sureties and/or documents confirming the financial circumstances of the suspect or accused person for the purpose of determining the possible amount of bail.
These documents directly contribute to the court's ability to deliver a lawful and well-reasoned decision.
How a Lawyer Assists in Modifying a Preventive Measure
The lawyer begins by carefully reviewing the case materials and assessing all grounds for modifying the restrictions. They assist in collecting the necessary certificates, medical reports and references confirming changes in the client's circumstances. The lawyer then prepares a legally sound motion and submits it to the court within the prescribed time limits.
During the hearing, the lawyer demonstrates that the existing risks do not justify the restrictive measure imposed and challenges the prosecutor's arguments. Where necessary, the lawyer promptly prepares an appeal against the preventive measure and provides legal support throughout the proceedings until a decision is delivered. Professional legal defence significantly improves the prospects of obtaining a modification of the preventive measure.
1
Step 1
Review of the Court Order, Risks and Evidence
2
Step 2
Preparation of a Motion or Appeal
3
Step 3
Representation at the Hearing and Monitoring Compliance with the Court Order
Cost of Legal Assistance
A Single Document, Court Hearing or Comprehensive Defence
The lawyer's fee depends on the scope of legal assistance, which may include:
- drafting an individual procedural document;
- representing the client's interests at a court hearing;
- comprehensive defence during the pre-trial investigation and/or court proceedings;
- developing an individual legal strategy.
The cost of services is agreed on an individual basis before the legal services agreement is signed.

