24 years of professional legal protection.

Protection of Honour, Dignity and Business Reputation

Protection of Honour, Dignity and Business Reputation

When false information about you or your company is published, the first step is to preserve the evidence and carefully assess what can actually be challenged. The right to protection of honour, dignity and business reputation has its limits: the law provides protection against false statements, but not against all forms of criticism.

8 min
Protection of Honour, Dignity and Business Reputation

What Information Can Be Challenged

Only statements that appear to present facts and infringe a person's rights can be challenged. The distinction is determined by the content of the publication, not its tone.

False Statements of Fact

Where false information concerns a specific person, that person may seek a retraction of the false information. The claimant must prove that the information was disseminated and that it concerns them, while the person who disseminated it must substantiate its accuracy.

Value Judgments, Criticism and Statements About Public Figures

A value judgment is an opinion that cannot be verified as true or false and is therefore not subject to retraction. Public figures are subject to wider limits of permissible criticism, as confirmed by the case law of the European Court of Human Rights. However, fabricated facts presented as opinions may be assessed differently by the court.

For an initial assessment, four elements should be examined:

  • What was disseminated: a statement of fact or an opinion, and whether it can be verified;
  • Who it concerns: whether a specific person or company can be identified;
  • Who became aware of it: whether the publication was publicly accessible and who its audience was;
  • Which rights were infringed: honour, dignity or business reputation, and what consequences followed.

If the answer to all four questions is positive, it is advisable to consult a lawyer who can help minimise the damage to the company.

How to Preserve Evidence and Identify the Defendant

Preserving evidence is the first practical step. Its quality may determine whether the court accepts the materials, which is why the protection of honour, dignity and business reputation begins even before a formal claim is sent.

Websites, Media Outlets, Social Media, Videos and Messaging Apps

For media publications, save the URL, date, time and full text, together with screenshots showing the address bar. A social media post should be documented along with the author's profile, views and comments. Videos and messages from messaging apps should be saved with the date and sender's contact details. The most reliable approach is to have the evidence secured by a notary or the court.

Electronic Evidence, the Author of a Publication and the Website Owner

Electronic evidence should contain metadata, while copies should include information about how they were created. The author can be identified through a signature, user account and publicly available information. A website owner can be identified through information held by the domain registrar and hosting provider. If the author is anonymous, the court may request relevant information from the resource administrator.

Pre-Trial Measures to Stop Reputational Harm

Out-of-court resolution is often faster and less expensive than litigation. A formal demand is sent to the author, editorial office or website owner, identifying the specific false information being challenged. Depending on the circumstances, the available measures include a retraction, the right of reply, removal of the material or negotiations.

RemedyWhen It AppliesResult
RetractionA verifiable but false statement has been disseminatedPublic acknowledgment that the statement was false, on the same platform where it was published
Right of replyA publication infringes a person's rights, but the editorial office is unwilling to issue a retractionPublication of the person's response on the same platform
RemovalThe material infringes a person's rights or violates platform rulesThe publication is made inaccessible, where necessary pursuant to a court order
NegotiationsThe author is known and willing to resolve the dispute voluntarilyAn agreement providing for removal, an apology or compensation

Court Protection of Honour, Dignity and Reputation

If an amicable resolution cannot be reached, the protection of honour, dignity and business reputation proceeds through the courts. A claim may be brought against the author or the website owner. Shorter limitation periods apply to certain claims.

Claims and the Burden of Proof

Typical claims include seeking a declaration that information is false, an order requiring its retraction, removal of the material, and compensation for moral and/or pecuniary damage. The claimant must prove that the information was disseminated, that it concerns them and that it had a negative impact. The defendant must prove the truthfulness of the information they disseminated. If the defendant fails to do so, the court will treat the information as false. A retraction must be published in the same form in which the original information was disseminated.

Moral and Pecuniary Damage: What Must Be Proven

Moral damage may include humiliation, emotional distress or the loss of business relationships. The court determines the amount of compensation taking into account the nature and scale of the dissemination. Pecuniary damage must be substantiated by calculations and supporting evidence, such as terminated contracts, lost orders and expenses incurred to mitigate the consequences. It is essential to establish a causal link between the publication and the losses incurred.

When Linguistic Analysis Is Required

Where the parties dispute whether a statement constitutes a statement of fact or a value judgment, a forensic linguistic examination may be commissioned. The expert analyses the text, its context and the manner in which it was presented. The expert opinion helps distinguish an opinion from a false factual statement.

Protection of a Company's Business Reputation

Protecting a company's business reputation has its own specific features: damage is measured in terms of customers, contracts and the trust of business partners. It is therefore important to promptly collect evidence of the consequences and coordinate communications with partners. Typical situations include:

  • Defamation in the media: a publication containing unsubstantiated allegations of fraud or misconduct;
  • False reviews: a wave of fake ratings intended to mislead customers;
  • Messages sent to business partners: emails or letters containing false information about the company;
  • Competitor attacks: coordinated publications designed to create the appearance of public opinion.

For each situation, collect relevant evidence, including a decline in enquiries, cancelled agreements and correspondence. Prepare a separate, measured statement for business partners.

How a Lawyer Organises the Work

Reputational disputes require a clear sequence of actions. Accordingly, the protection of honour, dignity and business reputation is organised into the following stages:

  • Evidence preservation – collecting evidence; the result is copies containing metadata or a notarial record.
  • Assessment – distinguishing statements of fact from opinions; the result is an assessment of the prospects of the case.
  • Strategy – choosing between an out-of-court and court-based approach; the result is an action plan.
  • Formal demand – sending a claim to the author or website owner; the result may be removal, retraction or refusal.
  • Court proceedings – filing a claim, presenting evidence and obtaining expert opinions; the result is a court judgment.
  • Enforcement – monitoring the publication of the retraction; the result is the actual removal or mitigation of the consequences.

Where appropriate, the matter may be concluded at the pre-trial stage.

What the Service Includes

The service covers the entire process:

  • Publication analysis: classifying statements and identifying the rights infringed;
  • Evidence collection: preserving evidence, securing evidence and arranging expert examinations;
  • Legal position: preparing legal arguments with due regard to the case law of the Supreme Court;
  • Formal demand or statement of claim: preparing and filing the relevant documents;
  • Representation: negotiations, court proceedings and enforcement of the judgment.

The scope of work is determined following an initial assessment.

Fees and Timeframes

Stage of AssistanceScope of WorkAdditional Costs
One-off assessmentReview of the publication and recommendation on the appropriate remedyUsually none
Pre-trial responseEvidence preservation, formal demand and negotiationsNotarial certification
Court disputeStatement of claim, representation and evidence preparationExpert examinations and court costs charged separately

Timeframes depend on the defendant and the remedy chosen. Voluntary removal may take just a few days, whereas court proceedings may last several months.

Lawyer for Reputation Disputes

The matter is handled by lawyer (full name), who has demonstrable experience in reputation disputes (list of credentials and cases).

Profile: (link).

A media lawyer works with editorial offices and online platforms. Consultations are available upon request.

Examples of Reputation Disputes

Example: A statement accusing a company of fraud was published on social media. The lawyer preserved evidence of the post and sent a formal demand for a retraction. After the demand was refused, a claim was filed with the court. The post was removed and a retraction was published. A prompt response is ensured by a media lawyer.

Full case study: (link).

What to Provide for an Initial Assessment

To assess the prospects of your case, please prepare the following materials:

  • a link to the publication and copies of the material;
  • screenshots showing the date and URL;
  • the date on which you became aware of the material;
  • details of the author or website owner, if known;
  • evidence of the consequences, such as correspondence and cancelled agreements.

You can still request an assessment even if you do not have all the materials.

Get a consultation

We’ll clarify the details and prepare a proposal

Contact banner
Name*
Phone number*
Email*
Convenient contact channel*
Email
Message*
I agree that Shkrebets and Partners stores my contact details and will send me updates, insights, and relevant information.

We usually respond via the form within 24 hours.

TelegramWhatsApp