

Danylo Mukhin
Paralegal
24 years of professional legal protection.

Appealing an investigating judge’s ruling imposing a preventive measure is an important procedural mechanism. However, its effectiveness directly depends on whether the contested ruling remains in force at the time the appeal is considered. If the ruling has expired and/or the preventive measure has been extended by a subsequent ruling, the appellate court is generally deprived of the procedural authority to set aside a decision that has already been enforced. Let us examine this legal position in more detail, based on the current case law of the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court and the Kyiv Court of Appeal.
In its ruling of 20 May 2019 in case No. 532/308/15-к (proceedings No. 13-23зво19), the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court set out a legal position that has become a guiding principle for appellate court practice in cases involving preventive measures:
“Setting aside a ruling imposing a preventive measure that has already been enforced cannot result in the restoration of any of the person’s rights.”
Although the above-mentioned position of the Grand Chamber concerned the consideration of a lawyer’s application for review on the basis of exceptional circumstances of the rulings issued by the Hadyach District Court of Poltava Region extending the term of a preventive measure, similar reasoning is also applied by appellate courts when dismissing appeals insofar as they seek to set aside rulings imposing preventive measures.
In its ruling of 8 May 2025 in case No. 761/9468/25, the panel of judges of the Kyiv Court of Appeal emphasised that the subject matter of appellate review is the investigating judge’s ruling, assessed in light of the circumstances that existed on the date it was issued, on the basis of and within the scope of the motion submitted by the investigator to the court of first instance:
“The subject matter of the appeal is the investigating judge’s ruling, which is reviewed on the basis of the circumstances of the criminal proceedings that existed on the date it was issued. The panel of judges is entitled to impose a preventive measure only on the basis of and within the scope of the motion submitted by the investigator to the court of first instance and is not authorised to decide on the imposition of a preventive measure for what would effectively be a new period that was not considered by the investigating judge of the local court [...]
[...] Given that, as of the date of the appellate hearing, the contested ruling of the investigating judge of the Shevchenkivskyi District Court of Kyiv dated 7 March 2025 had ceased to have effect on 6 May 2025, since this was the date until which it had been in force, the panel of judges is, in this case, deprived of the procedural authority to set aside the investigating judge’s ruling, which has already been enforced, and to issue a new ruling based on the investigator’s motion.”
As a result, the panel of judges concluded that the prosecutor’s appeal should be partially upheld; however, the investigating judge’s ruling remained unchanged due to the expiry of its validity period.
In its ruling of 2 October 2024 in case No. 757/35307/24-к, the panel of judges of the Kyiv Court of Appeal, when substantiating its decision, expressly referred to the fact that the preventive measure had been extended as of the date of consideration of the appeal:
“It follows from the above that, as of the date of consideration of the prosecutor’s appeal, the contested ruling of the investigating judge of the Pecherskyi District Court of Kyiv dated 8 August 2024 had ceased to have effect due to the extension of the preventive measure imposed on the suspect for a new period on 1 October 2024. According to the legal position of the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court set out in its ruling of 20 May 2019 in case No. 532/308/15-к (proceedings No. 13-23зво19), setting aside a ruling imposing a preventive measure that has already been enforced cannot, under any circumstances, result in the restoration of the person’s rights.”
In this case, the court dismissed the defence counsel’s appeal. At the same time, this legal position is also relevant to the opposite situation, namely, where it is necessary to challenge the arguments of the prosecution if it appeals against a ruling imposing a preventive measure.
This is further confirmed by the ruling of the Kyiv Court of Appeal dated 3 October 2024 in case No. 761/27908/24. When considering the prosecutor’s appeal against a ruling extending the term of a preventive measure, the panel of judges stated:
“[...] The panel of judges takes into account that, according to the information provided during the appellate proceedings, on 27 September 2024 the participants in these criminal proceedings were notified of the completion of the pre-trial investigation and granted access to the pre-trial investigation materials, and that, pursuant to the ruling of the investigating judge of the Shevchenkivskyi District Court of Kyiv dated 30 September 2024, the term of the obligations imposed on suspect ОСОБА_7 was extended. It follows from the above that, as of the date of consideration of the prosecutor’s appeal, the contested ruling of the investigating judge of the Shevchenkivskyi District Court of Kyiv dated 6 August 2024 had ceased to have effect due to the extension, on 30 September 2024, of the term of the obligations imposed on the suspect.”
Please fill out the form to contact our team.

We usually respond via the form within 24 hours.
Follow current legal analysis, legislative clarifications, and news from the attorneys of Shkrebets & Partners