

Sofiia Nechyporenko
Paralegal
24 years of professional legal protection.

Divorce or the parents’ separate residence does not release them from their obligation to care for their child, but it almost invariably raises the question of where the child will live permanently. Determining a child’s place of residence is not a mere formality, but a legally significant decision that affects the arrangements for contact with the other parent, the payment of child maintenance, the child’s registered place of residence and even the possibility of travelling abroad. Ukrainian legislation provides several ways to resolve this issue, ranging from a voluntary agreement between the parents to a court decision. This article examines each of them.
The law gives parents the right to decide independently which parent the child will live with. This is the primary and preferred option, since a jointly agreed decision is less likely to be challenged and is generally less traumatic for the child.
Pursuant to Part 1 of Article 160 of the Family Code of Ukraine, the place of residence of a child under the age of ten is determined by mutual agreement between the parents.
The place of residence of a child who has reached the age of ten is determined by mutual agreement between the parents and the child (Part 2 of Article 160 of the Family Code of Ukraine).
Under Part 3 of Article 160 of the Family Code of Ukraine, where the parents live separately, a child who has reached the age of fourteen determines their place of residence independently.
If the parents are not in conflict, they may reach a verbal agreement and simply follow the agreed arrangements in practice. However, a verbal agreement has no evidentiary value. Therefore, lawyers recommend formalising the arrangement in writing in the form of an agreement on determining the child’s place of residence and the other parent’s participation in the child’s upbringing. Such an agreement should be notarised.
Where the parents cannot reach an agreement independently, the law allows them to apply to the guardianship and custody authority at the child’s place of residence.
Under Part 1 of Article 161 of the Family Code of Ukraine, if a mother and father who live separately cannot agree on which of them their minor child will live with, the dispute may be resolved by the guardianship and custody authority or by a court.
This is an out-of-court, free-of-charge and generally faster way to resolve the dispute. The guardianship authority examines the living conditions of each parent, hears their explanations and, where necessary, those of the child, and then prepares an opinion on the most appropriate place of residence for the child.
It is important to understand that the guardianship authority’s decision is recommendatory rather than final. Either party who disagrees with it retains the right to apply to court.
If an agreement is impossible and one of the parties is dissatisfied with the guardianship authority’s decision, the dispute is ultimately resolved by a court. The court independently examines all the circumstances of the case and the evidence, including the guardianship authority’s opinion, and delivers a decision guided primarily by the child’s best interests rather than the parents’ wishes.
The child’s age directly affects who makes the decision concerning their place of residence and how that decision is made. Until the child reaches the age of ten, the matter is decided exclusively by the parents through mutual agreement. Once the child reaches the age of ten, their opinion is taken into account alongside the parents’ positions. Although it is not yet decisive, the court or guardianship authority is required to ascertain and assess it. A child who has reached the age of fourteen independently determines which parent they will live with if their parents live separately. This is no longer a matter of agreement but a personal right of the child.
In practice, courts ascertain the child’s opinion in a manner appropriate to their age and psychological condition: through an interview in the presence of a psychologist, with the participation of a representative of the children’s services, and without pressure from either parent.
The law expressly establishes a list of circumstances that are of material importance when resolving a dispute concerning the place of residence of a minor child.
Under Parts 1 and 2 of Article 161 of the Family Code of Ukraine, if a mother and father who live separately cannot agree on which of them their minor child will live with, the dispute may be resolved by the guardianship and custody authority or by a court. When resolving a dispute concerning the place of residence of a minor child, consideration is given to the parents’ attitude towards fulfilling their parental responsibilities, the child’s personal attachment to each parent, the child’s age, their state of health and other circumstances of material importance.
The following factors are taken into account when resolving a dispute concerning the place of residence of a minor child: the parents’ attitude towards fulfilling their parental responsibilities, the child’s personal attachment to each parent, the child’s age, their state of health and other circumstances of material importance.
The court assesses how each parent actually fulfilled their obligations to maintain, raise and care for the child before the dispute arose: whether they participated in the child’s everyday life, paid child maintenance, and showed an interest in the child’s health and education. Their formal status as a “father” or “mother” is not decisive; what matters is their actual involvement.
The child’s emotional attachment to each parent, as well as the stability of their familiar environment – school, social circle and everyday routine – are among the most important factors. Courts seek to avoid abrupt changes to the child’s established way of life unless such changes are required for the child’s safety or interests.
The living conditions of each parent are assessed, including whether the child has a separate space, the sanitary condition of the accommodation and its distance from the child’s school or kindergarten. The stability of income and the general state of health of both parents are also taken into account. However, as the Supreme Court has repeatedly emphasised, better financial circumstances alone are not a decisive argument.
Above all else, the court is guided by the principle of the child’s best interests. This is a fundamental standard enshrined in the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child and consistently applied by Ukrainian courts. The child’s safety, including their physical and psychological well-being, takes priority over all other considerations, including the parents’ wishes.
Under Article 3 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, in all actions concerning children, whether undertaken by public or private social welfare institutions, courts, administrative authorities or legislative bodies, the best interests of the child shall be a primary consideration.
Regardless of whether the matter is resolved voluntarily, through the guardianship authority or in court, a basic set of documents will be required:
When applying to court, this list is supplemented by the statement of claim, a receipt confirming payment of the court fee and the evidence relied upon by the claimant to support their legal position.
Disputes concerning a child’s place of residence are among the categories of cases in which formal evidence is often insufficient. The court assesses the totality of information about the child’s and both parents’ actual circumstances and everyday lives.
Written references from the workplace, neighbours, kindergarten or school help establish an objective picture of each parent’s lifestyle. A report on the inspection of living and housing conditions prepared by the guardianship authority records the actual condition of the accommodation, including whether the child has a separate sleeping place, toys and educational supplies – all of which indicate the parent’s readiness to provide a permanent home for the child.
The court may consider witness testimony from relatives, caregivers, teachers and neighbours who have directly observed the child’s everyday life. Correspondence between the parents, including messages exchanged through messaging applications, may also have evidentiary value if it confirms the circumstances of the case. The court may further consider opinions issued by a psychologist or another specialist concerning the child’s emotional state and the nature of their attachment to each parent.
The participation of the guardianship and custody authority is mandatory in proceedings concerning the determination of a child’s place of residence. A court cannot hear such a dispute without its opinion.
The guardianship and custody authority submits to the court a written opinion on the resolution of the dispute, based on information obtained through inspections of the living conditions of the child, the parents and other persons who wish to live with the child or participate in their upbringing, as well as on the basis of other documents relevant to the case.
The court may disagree with the opinion of the guardianship and custody authority if it is insufficiently substantiated or contradicts the child’s interests.
Thus, the guardianship authority’s opinion is important evidence, but it is not binding in an absolute sense. If the opinion was prepared formally, without an actual inspection of living conditions or without hearing the child, the court is entitled to reject it and deliver its own decision based on other evidence.
A statement of claim must be submitted in writing in accordance with the requirements of the Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine. It must contain the name of the court, the details of the claimant and defendant, the circumstances of the case, references to the evidence, clearly formulated claims (for example, “to determine that the child’s place of residence shall be with the mother/father at the address...”) and a list of attachments.
A claim for determining a child’s place of residence must be filed with the court at the defendant’s place of residence, in accordance with the requirements of civil procedural law. The parties to the proceedings are the child’s parents, while the guardianship and custody authority is involved as a third party that does not assert independent claims. The court fee for filing a non-monetary claim is established by the legislation on court fees and must be paid.
In its judgments, the Supreme Court consistently emphasises that the key and effectively decisive criterion in disputes of this category is the child’s best interests, rather than the gender, income or housing conditions of either parent. The court assesses the evidence in its entirety, systematically ascertains the child’s opinion through a proper examination of the circumstances rather than a merely formal interview, and should not rely exclusively on the guardianship authority’s opinion if it is insufficiently substantiated.
The full-scale invasion and martial law have significantly affected the practice of resolving such disputes. If a child has been evacuated abroad with one parent while the other parent has remained in Ukraine or insists that the child return, courts primarily assess the actual safety of the child’s stay in the particular location and only then consider all the other traditional criteria. A child’s temporary stay abroad due to hostilities does not, in itself, indicate a violation of the other parent’s rights if the decision was prompted by safety considerations.
A court decision determining a child’s place of residence is binding on both parents. If the parent with whom the child is to live under the court decision encounters obstacles created by the other parent, they may apply to the State Enforcement Service for compulsory enforcement of the decision. The children’s services and the police may be involved in facilitating the transfer of the child if voluntary compliance with the decision is impossible. Failure to comply with a court decision entails legal liability for the party evading its enforcement.
A previously adopted court decision or an agreement reached by the parents is not necessarily permanent. If the circumstances change significantly – for example, the child’s living conditions deteriorate, one parent’s attitude towards fulfilling their parental responsibilities changes, the child reaches an age at which they can independently express their opinion, or new circumstances arise affecting the child’s safety – an interested party has the right to file a new claim with the court seeking to change the child’s place of residence. A court decision is not reviewed automatically: the change in circumstances must be proven.
If a dispute arises between parents concerning their child’s place of residence, its resolution should not be postponed. Every case has its own specific circumstances, and mistakes made at the initial stage may significantly affect the outcome of the proceedings. The lawyers at Attorney Association “Shkrebets & Partners” can help assess the prospects of the case, prepare the necessary evidence, represent your interests before the guardianship and custody authority and in court, and take all possible measures to ensure that the decision serves the child’s best interests. Contact us for a consultation to receive professional legal assistance and protect your rights and those of your child.
Please fill out the form to contact our team.

We usually respond via the form within 24 hours.
Follow current legal analysis, legislative clarifications, and news from the attorneys of Shkrebets & Partners