

Danylo Mukhin
Paralegal
24 years of professional legal protection.

During pre-trial investigations, investigators often require witnesses to disclose the password to their mobile phones, laptops or other electronic devices. This raises a legitimate question: can failure to provide such a password be regarded as a witness's refusal to testify and constitute grounds for criminal liability under Article 385 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine?
Pursuant to Parts 1, 3 and 5 of Article 95 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine (CPC), testimony means information provided orally or in writing during questioning by a suspect, accused person, witness, victim or expert concerning circumstances known to them in criminal proceedings and relevant to those proceedings.
Part 1 of Article 385 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine establishes criminal liability for a witness's refusal to testify during pre-trial investigations or in court.
However, there are important exceptions.
a person shall not be held liable for refusing to give testimony or explanations concerning themselves, their family members or close relatives, where such information may constitute grounds for suspecting or accusing them of committing a criminal offence.
Part 8 of Article 224 of the CPC also provides that a person has the right not to answer questions concerning circumstances in respect of which the law expressly prohibits disclosure, as well as questions concerning officials conducting covert investigative (search) actions and persons who confidentially cooperate with pre-trial investigation authorities.
Furthermore, criminal liability may arise only if the witness has been duly warned of criminal liability for refusing to testify.
The CPC of Ukraine does not expressly define whether a password can be considered testimony. Whether a logical security mechanism may, in a particular case, be regarded as relating to circumstances relevant to criminal proceedings is a debatable issue.
At the same time, it can confidently be stated that disclosing a password effectively grants access to information stored on the relevant electronic device. For this reason, we believe that the issue is not purely technical and may be connected with the exercise of a person's right not to incriminate themselves.
If a person has reasonable grounds to believe that information stored on a phone, computer or other storage device may be used to formulate a suspicion or accusation against them, their close relatives or family members, refusal to disclose the password should be regarded as the exercise of a constitutional right rather than a criminally punishable refusal to testify.
Similarly, a person may also rely on Part 8 of Article 224 of the CPC when refusing to disclose a password, provided that the device contains information that is expressly protected from disclosure by law (such as the secrecy of confession, medical confidentiality, legal professional privilege, the secrecy of the deliberations room, etc.), or information that may concern officials conducting covert investigative (search) actions and persons who confidentially cooperate with pre-trial investigation authorities.
A different situation may arise where there are no objective grounds to believe that the information stored on the device could constitute grounds for suspecting or accusing the witness, their close relatives or family members of a criminal offence.
For example, if a witness is a company's system administrator and has access to a password exclusively for the performance of their professional duties, while access to the information is in no way connected with possible self-incrimination or testimony against close relatives or family members, the investigation may potentially regard such refusal as an unjustified failure to fulfil the witness's obligations.
In such a case, it is necessary to assess whether the device may contain information that is expressly protected from disclosure by law. It follows that each situation requires an individual legal assessment taking into account the specific circumstances of the criminal proceedings.
Providing a password to a particular information storage device may be regarded as granting access to the information contained therein. However, if a witness has sufficient grounds to believe that such information may constitute grounds for suspecting or accusing them, their close relatives or family members of committing a criminal offence, then, in our opinion, the witness has the right to refuse to provide such testimony.
We believe that, under the circumstances described above, a witness also has the right not to answer questions concerning the password if they have sufficient grounds to believe that the device contains information that is expressly protected from disclosure by law.
Conversely, where there are objectively no grounds to believe that the device contains such information, refusal to testify may, depending on the specific circumstances of the criminal proceedings, be deemed unjustified and result in criminal liability. At the same time, we note that there are currently no legal conclusions of the Supreme Court on this issue, nor is there any established case law. Therefore, the position presented is based exclusively on our own analysis of the provisions of the current legislation.
This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute individual legal advice. If, during questioning, you are required to disclose the password to an electronic device or have doubts about your procedural rights, you should consider seeking legal assistance from a lawyer.
Please fill out the form to contact our team.

We usually respond via the form within 24 hours.
Follow current legal analysis, legislative clarifications, and news from the attorneys of Shkrebets & Partners